The phosphorus negotiation game (P-Game): first evaluation of a serious game to support science-policy decision making played in more than 20 countries worldwide
Abstract Environmental negotiations are complex, and conveying the interaction between science and policy in traditional teaching methods is challenging. To address this issue, innovative educational approaches like serious gaming and role-playing games have emerged. These methods allow students to...
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Springer
2025-01-01
|
| Series: | Discover Sustainability |
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1007/s43621-024-00693-6 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1841559897451266048 |
|---|---|
| author | Nils Haneklaus Mary Kaggwa Jane Misihairabgwi Sherif Abu El-Magd Naima Ahmadi Jamal Ait Brahim Aloyce Amasi Andrea Balláné Kovács Łukasz Bartela Hajar Bellefqih Redouane Beniazza Jaroslav Bernas Essaid Bilal Tomislav Bituh Yelizaveta Chernysh Viktoriia Chubur Jelena Ćirić Claudia Dolezal Andrea Figulová Janja Filipi Gordana Glavan Tibor Guzsvinecz László Horváth Sasho Josimovski Martin Kiselicki Maja Lazarus Maja Kazazić István Komlósi Ali Maged Tebogo Mashifana Gordana Medunić Emina Mehić Felhi Mongi Kelvin Mtei Dennis Mwalongo Jerome Mwimanzi Jakub Nowak Oqba Basal Khaoula Qamouche Małgorzata Rajfur Hynek Roubík Mijalche Santa Cecília Sik-Lányi Maike Sippel Gerald Steiner Anna Skorek-Osikowska Anton Slavov Paweł Świsłowski Ali Tlili Kalina Trenevska-Blagoeva Ivan Tschalakov Tomáš Vlček Stanisław Wacławek Ivan Zlatanović Matúš Mišík Hendrik Brink Tzong-Ru Lee |
| author_facet | Nils Haneklaus Mary Kaggwa Jane Misihairabgwi Sherif Abu El-Magd Naima Ahmadi Jamal Ait Brahim Aloyce Amasi Andrea Balláné Kovács Łukasz Bartela Hajar Bellefqih Redouane Beniazza Jaroslav Bernas Essaid Bilal Tomislav Bituh Yelizaveta Chernysh Viktoriia Chubur Jelena Ćirić Claudia Dolezal Andrea Figulová Janja Filipi Gordana Glavan Tibor Guzsvinecz László Horváth Sasho Josimovski Martin Kiselicki Maja Lazarus Maja Kazazić István Komlósi Ali Maged Tebogo Mashifana Gordana Medunić Emina Mehić Felhi Mongi Kelvin Mtei Dennis Mwalongo Jerome Mwimanzi Jakub Nowak Oqba Basal Khaoula Qamouche Małgorzata Rajfur Hynek Roubík Mijalche Santa Cecília Sik-Lányi Maike Sippel Gerald Steiner Anna Skorek-Osikowska Anton Slavov Paweł Świsłowski Ali Tlili Kalina Trenevska-Blagoeva Ivan Tschalakov Tomáš Vlček Stanisław Wacławek Ivan Zlatanović Matúš Mišík Hendrik Brink Tzong-Ru Lee |
| author_sort | Nils Haneklaus |
| collection | DOAJ |
| description | Abstract Environmental negotiations are complex, and conveying the interaction between science and policy in traditional teaching methods is challenging. To address this issue, innovative educational approaches like serious gaming and role-playing games have emerged. These methods allow students to actively explore the roles of different stakeholders in environmental decision-making and weigh for instance between sometimes conflicting UN Sustainable Development Goals or other dilemmas. In this work the phosphorus negotiation game (P-Game) is for the first time introduced. We present the initial quantitative and qualitative findings derived from engaging 788 students at various academic levels (Bachelor, Master, PhD, and Postdoc) across three continents and spanning 22 different countries. Quantitative results indicate that female participants and MSc students benefitted the most significantly from the P-Game, with their self-reported knowledge about phosphorus science and negotiation science/practice increasing by 71–93% (overall), 86–100% (females), and 73–106% (MSc students in general). Qualitative findings reveal that the P-Game can be smoothly conducted with students from diverse educational and cultural backgrounds. Moreover, students highly value their participation in the P-Game, which can be completed in just 2–3 h. This game not only encourages active engagement among participants but also provides valuable insights into the complex environmental issues associated with global phosphorus production. We strongly believe that the underlying methodology described here could also be used for other topics. |
| format | Article |
| id | doaj-art-97f67a08191b48dfb29bd102c1da3ff0 |
| institution | Kabale University |
| issn | 2662-9984 |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2025-01-01 |
| publisher | Springer |
| record_format | Article |
| series | Discover Sustainability |
| spelling | doaj-art-97f67a08191b48dfb29bd102c1da3ff02025-01-05T12:05:19ZengSpringerDiscover Sustainability2662-99842025-01-016111610.1007/s43621-024-00693-6The phosphorus negotiation game (P-Game): first evaluation of a serious game to support science-policy decision making played in more than 20 countries worldwideNils Haneklaus0Mary Kaggwa1Jane Misihairabgwi2Sherif Abu El-Magd3Naima Ahmadi4Jamal Ait Brahim5Aloyce Amasi6Andrea Balláné Kovács7Łukasz Bartela8Hajar Bellefqih9Redouane Beniazza10Jaroslav Bernas11Essaid Bilal12Tomislav Bituh13Yelizaveta Chernysh14Viktoriia Chubur15Jelena Ćirić16Claudia Dolezal17Andrea Figulová18Janja Filipi19Gordana Glavan20Tibor Guzsvinecz21László Horváth22Sasho Josimovski23Martin Kiselicki24Maja Lazarus25Maja Kazazić26István Komlósi27Ali Maged28Tebogo Mashifana29Gordana Medunić30Emina Mehić31Felhi Mongi32Kelvin Mtei33Dennis Mwalongo34Jerome Mwimanzi35Jakub Nowak36Oqba Basal37Khaoula Qamouche38Małgorzata Rajfur39Hynek Roubík40Mijalche Santa41Cecília Sik-Lányi42Maike Sippel43Gerald Steiner44Anna Skorek-Osikowska45Anton Slavov46Paweł Świsłowski47Ali Tlili48Kalina Trenevska-Blagoeva49Ivan Tschalakov50Tomáš Vlček51Stanisław Wacławek52Ivan Zlatanović53Matúš Mišík54Hendrik Brink55Tzong-Ru Lee56University for Continuing Education KremsDepartment of Environmental Science, Kyambogo UniversityHuman, Biological and Translational Medical Sciences, University of NamibiaGeology Department, Faculty of Science, Suez UniversityDepartment of Earth Sciences, University of SfaxInstitute of Science, Technology & Innovation (IST&I), Mohammed VI Polytechnic University (UM6P)Nelson Mandela African Institution of Science and Technology (NM-AIST)Institute of Agricultural Chemistry and Soil Science, Faculty of Agricultural and Food Sciences and Environmental Management, University of DebrecenDepartment of Power Engineering and Turbomachinery, Silesian University of TechnologyEcole Nationale Supérieure Des Mines de Saint Etienne, CNRS UMR, EVSInstitute of Science, Technology & Innovation (IST&I), Mohammed VI Polytechnic University (UM6P)Department of Agroecosystems, Faculty of Agriculture and Technology, University of South Bohemia in České BudějoviceEcole Nationale Supérieure Des Mines de Saint Etienne, CNRS UMR, EVSInstitute for Medical Research and Occupational HealthDepartment of Sustainable Technologies, Faculty of Tropical AgriSciences, Czech University of Life SciencesDepartment of Sustainable Technologies, Faculty of Tropical AgriSciences, Czech University of Life SciencesInstitute of Meat Hygiene and TechnologyInstitute of Tourism, Department of Business, IMC Krems University of Applied SciencesFaculty of Social and Economic Sciences, Comenius University BratislavaDepartment of Ecology, Agronomy and Aquaculture, University of ZadarDepartment of Biology, Biotechnical Faculty, University of LjubljanaDepartment of Information Technology and Its Applications, Faculty of Information Technology, University of PannoniaDepartment of Electrical Engineering and Information Systems, Faculty of Information Technology, University of PannoniaFaculty of Economics, Ss. Cyril and Methodius University in SkopjeFaculty of Economics, Ss. Cyril and Methodius University in SkopjeInstitute for Medical Research and Occupational HealthDzemal Bijedic University of MostarInstitute of Agricultural Chemistry and Soil Science, Faculty of Agricultural and Food Sciences and Environmental Management, University of DebrecenGeology Department, Faculty of Science, Suez UniversityDepartment of Chemical Engineering, School of Mining and Chemical Engineering, University of JohannesburgFaculty of Science, Department of Geology, University of ZagrebDzemal Bijedic University of MostarDepartment of Earth Sciences, University of SfaxNelson Mandela African Institution of Science and Technology (NM-AIST)Nelson Mandela African Institution of Science and Technology (NM-AIST)Nelson Mandela African Institution of Science and Technology (NM-AIST)Faculty of Physics and Applied Computer Science, AGH University of Science and TechnologyDepartment of Applied Plant Biology, Faculty of Agricultural and Food Sciences and Environmental Management, University of DebrecenUniversity for Continuing Education KremsInstitute of Biology, University of OpoleDepartment of Sustainable Technologies, Faculty of Tropical AgriSciences, Czech University of Life SciencesFaculty of Economics, Ss. Cyril and Methodius University in SkopjeDepartment of Electrical Engineering and Information Systems, Faculty of Information Technology, University of PannoniaHTWG Konstanz University of Applied SciencesUniversity for Continuing Education KremsDepartment of Power Engineering and Turbomachinery, Silesian University of TechnologyDepartment of Organic and Inorganic Chemistry, Technological Faculty, University of Food TechnologiesInstitute of Biology, University of OpoleDepartment of Earth Sciences, University of SfaxFaculty of Economics, Ss. Cyril and Methodius University in SkopjeDepartment of Institutional and Applied Sociology, Paisii Hilendarski University of PlovdivDepartment of International Relations and European Studies, Faculty of Social Studies, Masaryk UniversityInstitute for Nanomaterials, Advanced Technologies, and Innovation, Technical University of LiberecFaculty of Mechanical Engineering, University of BelgradeDepartment of Political Science, Faculty of Arts, Comenius University BratislavaDepartment of Chemical Engineering, University of PretoriaDepartment of Marketing, National Chung Hsing UniversityAbstract Environmental negotiations are complex, and conveying the interaction between science and policy in traditional teaching methods is challenging. To address this issue, innovative educational approaches like serious gaming and role-playing games have emerged. These methods allow students to actively explore the roles of different stakeholders in environmental decision-making and weigh for instance between sometimes conflicting UN Sustainable Development Goals or other dilemmas. In this work the phosphorus negotiation game (P-Game) is for the first time introduced. We present the initial quantitative and qualitative findings derived from engaging 788 students at various academic levels (Bachelor, Master, PhD, and Postdoc) across three continents and spanning 22 different countries. Quantitative results indicate that female participants and MSc students benefitted the most significantly from the P-Game, with their self-reported knowledge about phosphorus science and negotiation science/practice increasing by 71–93% (overall), 86–100% (females), and 73–106% (MSc students in general). Qualitative findings reveal that the P-Game can be smoothly conducted with students from diverse educational and cultural backgrounds. Moreover, students highly value their participation in the P-Game, which can be completed in just 2–3 h. This game not only encourages active engagement among participants but also provides valuable insights into the complex environmental issues associated with global phosphorus production. We strongly believe that the underlying methodology described here could also be used for other topics.https://doi.org/10.1007/s43621-024-00693-6Environmental decision-makingSustainable development goalsPhosphorusSerious gameTeaching |
| spellingShingle | Nils Haneklaus Mary Kaggwa Jane Misihairabgwi Sherif Abu El-Magd Naima Ahmadi Jamal Ait Brahim Aloyce Amasi Andrea Balláné Kovács Łukasz Bartela Hajar Bellefqih Redouane Beniazza Jaroslav Bernas Essaid Bilal Tomislav Bituh Yelizaveta Chernysh Viktoriia Chubur Jelena Ćirić Claudia Dolezal Andrea Figulová Janja Filipi Gordana Glavan Tibor Guzsvinecz László Horváth Sasho Josimovski Martin Kiselicki Maja Lazarus Maja Kazazić István Komlósi Ali Maged Tebogo Mashifana Gordana Medunić Emina Mehić Felhi Mongi Kelvin Mtei Dennis Mwalongo Jerome Mwimanzi Jakub Nowak Oqba Basal Khaoula Qamouche Małgorzata Rajfur Hynek Roubík Mijalche Santa Cecília Sik-Lányi Maike Sippel Gerald Steiner Anna Skorek-Osikowska Anton Slavov Paweł Świsłowski Ali Tlili Kalina Trenevska-Blagoeva Ivan Tschalakov Tomáš Vlček Stanisław Wacławek Ivan Zlatanović Matúš Mišík Hendrik Brink Tzong-Ru Lee The phosphorus negotiation game (P-Game): first evaluation of a serious game to support science-policy decision making played in more than 20 countries worldwide Discover Sustainability Environmental decision-making Sustainable development goals Phosphorus Serious game Teaching |
| title | The phosphorus negotiation game (P-Game): first evaluation of a serious game to support science-policy decision making played in more than 20 countries worldwide |
| title_full | The phosphorus negotiation game (P-Game): first evaluation of a serious game to support science-policy decision making played in more than 20 countries worldwide |
| title_fullStr | The phosphorus negotiation game (P-Game): first evaluation of a serious game to support science-policy decision making played in more than 20 countries worldwide |
| title_full_unstemmed | The phosphorus negotiation game (P-Game): first evaluation of a serious game to support science-policy decision making played in more than 20 countries worldwide |
| title_short | The phosphorus negotiation game (P-Game): first evaluation of a serious game to support science-policy decision making played in more than 20 countries worldwide |
| title_sort | phosphorus negotiation game p game first evaluation of a serious game to support science policy decision making played in more than 20 countries worldwide |
| topic | Environmental decision-making Sustainable development goals Phosphorus Serious game Teaching |
| url | https://doi.org/10.1007/s43621-024-00693-6 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT nilshaneklaus thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT marykaggwa thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT janemisihairabgwi thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT sherifabuelmagd thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT naimaahmadi thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT jamalaitbrahim thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT aloyceamasi thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT andreaballanekovacs thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT łukaszbartela thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT hajarbellefqih thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT redouanebeniazza thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT jaroslavbernas thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT essaidbilal thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT tomislavbituh thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT yelizavetachernysh thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT viktoriiachubur thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT jelenaciric thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT claudiadolezal thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT andreafigulova thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT janjafilipi thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT gordanaglavan thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT tiborguzsvinecz thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT laszlohorvath thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT sashojosimovski thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT martinkiselicki thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT majalazarus thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT majakazazic thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT istvankomlosi thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT alimaged thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT tebogomashifana thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT gordanamedunic thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT eminamehic thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT felhimongi thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT kelvinmtei thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT dennismwalongo thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT jeromemwimanzi thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT jakubnowak thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT oqbabasal thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT khaoulaqamouche thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT małgorzatarajfur thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT hynekroubik thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT mijalchesanta thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT ceciliasiklanyi thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT maikesippel thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT geraldsteiner thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT annaskorekosikowska thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT antonslavov thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT pawełswisłowski thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT alitlili thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT kalinatrenevskablagoeva thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT ivantschalakov thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT tomasvlcek thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT stanisławwacławek thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT ivanzlatanovic thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT matusmisik thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT hendrikbrink thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT tzongrulee thephosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT nilshaneklaus phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT marykaggwa phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT janemisihairabgwi phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT sherifabuelmagd phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT naimaahmadi phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT jamalaitbrahim phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT aloyceamasi phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT andreaballanekovacs phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT łukaszbartela phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT hajarbellefqih phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT redouanebeniazza phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT jaroslavbernas phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT essaidbilal phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT tomislavbituh phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT yelizavetachernysh phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT viktoriiachubur phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT jelenaciric phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT claudiadolezal phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT andreafigulova phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT janjafilipi phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT gordanaglavan phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT tiborguzsvinecz phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT laszlohorvath phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT sashojosimovski phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT martinkiselicki phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT majalazarus phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT majakazazic phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT istvankomlosi phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT alimaged phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT tebogomashifana phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT gordanamedunic phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT eminamehic phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT felhimongi phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT kelvinmtei phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT dennismwalongo phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT jeromemwimanzi phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT jakubnowak phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT oqbabasal phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT khaoulaqamouche phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT małgorzatarajfur phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT hynekroubik phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT mijalchesanta phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT ceciliasiklanyi phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT maikesippel phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT geraldsteiner phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT annaskorekosikowska phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT antonslavov phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT pawełswisłowski phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT alitlili phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT kalinatrenevskablagoeva phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT ivantschalakov phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT tomasvlcek phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT stanisławwacławek phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT ivanzlatanovic phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT matusmisik phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT hendrikbrink phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide AT tzongrulee phosphorusnegotiationgamepgamefirstevaluationofaseriousgametosupportsciencepolicydecisionmakingplayedinmorethan20countriesworldwide |