Legitimising EU Governance through Performance Assessment Instruments

The article addresses the production of indicators as policy instruments in European public policy. It discusses the relevant literature on sociology of quantification and European public policy and applies this theoretical framework to the case of European judicial administration policy. Presenting...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Bartolomeo Cappellina
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: OpenEdition 2020-09-01
Series:International Review of Public Policy
Subjects:
Online Access:https://journals.openedition.org/irpp/1023
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1841551181565919232
author Bartolomeo Cappellina
author_facet Bartolomeo Cappellina
author_sort Bartolomeo Cappellina
collection DOAJ
description The article addresses the production of indicators as policy instruments in European public policy. It discusses the relevant literature on sociology of quantification and European public policy and applies this theoretical framework to the case of European judicial administration policy. Presenting the historical and institutional premises to the creation of two projects of judicial performance assessment by the Council of Europe and the European Commission, as well as their methodology, the article argues that the selection of indicators is a litmus test of debates over the strategies and institutional goals of the organisations proposing them. Connecting the previous analysis with the use of these instruments in the policy-making sphere, the article points out that evaluation tools in European policy, rather than serving merely as informative tools, produce empowerment side-effects in the policy arena for the organisations that developed them. In European judicial policy, indicators provide a sufficiently loose framework to solve vertical and horizontal cooperation problems at the international level, determine policy goals through the selection of areas of measurement and evaluation, and provide proof to influence local and national policy-makers over reforms either through lesson-drawing, persuasion or conditionality.
format Article
id doaj-art-69d94588d6d649039c47053cb3d1cc7c
institution Kabale University
issn 2679-3873
2706-6274
language English
publishDate 2020-09-01
publisher OpenEdition
record_format Article
series International Review of Public Policy
spelling doaj-art-69d94588d6d649039c47053cb3d1cc7c2025-01-09T16:25:56ZengOpenEditionInternational Review of Public Policy2679-38732706-62742020-09-01214115810.4000/irpp.1023Legitimising EU Governance through Performance Assessment InstrumentsBartolomeo CappellinaThe article addresses the production of indicators as policy instruments in European public policy. It discusses the relevant literature on sociology of quantification and European public policy and applies this theoretical framework to the case of European judicial administration policy. Presenting the historical and institutional premises to the creation of two projects of judicial performance assessment by the Council of Europe and the European Commission, as well as their methodology, the article argues that the selection of indicators is a litmus test of debates over the strategies and institutional goals of the organisations proposing them. Connecting the previous analysis with the use of these instruments in the policy-making sphere, the article points out that evaluation tools in European policy, rather than serving merely as informative tools, produce empowerment side-effects in the policy arena for the organisations that developed them. In European judicial policy, indicators provide a sufficiently loose framework to solve vertical and horizontal cooperation problems at the international level, determine policy goals through the selection of areas of measurement and evaluation, and provide proof to influence local and national policy-makers over reforms either through lesson-drawing, persuasion or conditionality.https://journals.openedition.org/irpp/1023European Commissionpolicy instrumentsjusticepolicy changeindicatorsblame avoidance
spellingShingle Bartolomeo Cappellina
Legitimising EU Governance through Performance Assessment Instruments
International Review of Public Policy
European Commission
policy instruments
justice
policy change
indicators
blame avoidance
title Legitimising EU Governance through Performance Assessment Instruments
title_full Legitimising EU Governance through Performance Assessment Instruments
title_fullStr Legitimising EU Governance through Performance Assessment Instruments
title_full_unstemmed Legitimising EU Governance through Performance Assessment Instruments
title_short Legitimising EU Governance through Performance Assessment Instruments
title_sort legitimising eu governance through performance assessment instruments
topic European Commission
policy instruments
justice
policy change
indicators
blame avoidance
url https://journals.openedition.org/irpp/1023
work_keys_str_mv AT bartolomeocappellina legitimisingeugovernancethroughperformanceassessmentinstruments